Rocket Talk: Place-Making vs Place-Keeping: Dave Loewenstein, Sara Taliaferro, and the USDAC

 

IMG_3628On Saturday, February 6th at La Esquina, just after Jessica Borusky and Judith G. Levy’s cross-dialogue on Persona and Place, visitors wandered about the gallery while technicians and members of the U.S. Department of Arts and Culture (USDAC) prepared  for the facilitated discussion about to take place.

A group of chairs were positioned in a circle, and two tables were set up with name tags for everyone who had been invited to participate . There were snacks, pens, and markers, so it  promised  to be an enjoyable time.

IMG_3637

Dave Loewenstein and Sara Taliaferro explained  that they would be the core facilitators for this event, and asked the “official guests” to introduce themselves.

IMG_3638

Invited participants  were:

Sara Taliaferro, artist and USDAC facilitator

Robert Baker, Resource Development Director for Lawrence Tenants to Home Owners (also current Rocket Grants recipient)

Chris Lempa, Youth Program Coordinator and East Lawrence Resident

Kate Dinneen, East Ninth Associate Artist and Lawrence Cultural Arts Commissioner

Dave Loewenstein, artist and USDAC facilitator

Julia Cole, Rocket Grants Program Coordinator

Thomas Morefield, BNIM architect

Nick Carswell, East Ninth Street Artist and Program Manager with Kansas Audio Reader

KT Walsh, artist and East Lawrence Neighborhood Association board member

John Hachmeister, KU Sculpture professor and East Lawrence property owner

Lane Eisenbart, writer and East Lawrence Neighborhood Association Coordinator

Vladimir Krstic, professor and Director of the Kansas City Design Center

Jose Faus, artist, writer and teacher.

IMG_3616

Dave and the USDAC emailed out materials to read before the discussion, including  a description of the dialogue and  an essay written by Roberto Bedoya, the Executive Director of the Tucson Pima Arts Council and a USDAC National Cabinet member.

Collaborators split up into two groups, and  Dave Loewenstein and Sara Taliaferro facilitated  discussions about Roberto Bedoya’s essay and posed some  initial questions.

Bedoya’s essay was asking an audience of community-engaged artists and organizers to analyze Creative Placemaking Projects from the perspective of whether they center belonging. He argues that projects that fail to perceive this aspect as essential to cultural and social navigation end up doing harm to the communities they seek to improve.

IMG_3915

The essay asserts that we need to be careful not to let artists be instrumentalized into a development strategy, but rather that we think of Creative Placemaking as “a series of actions that build spatial justice, healthy communities, and sites of imagination.”

IMG_3712

Dave and Sara led their collaborators through several different imaginary scenarios, and the premise of the first conversation was to share a story where you encountered something difficult culturally or socially, and then describe how you went about navigating that. There was to be no cross-dialogue at this point, so judgement would not shut down a simple,  shared experience.

IMG_3805IMG_3898

Then , Sara and Dave pulled out a hat containing slips of paper, so each person could randomly select a persona to assume for a discussion about community development projects.

IMG_3690

Identities ranged in age, role and ethnicity (from a 13-year-old schoolboy to a single mother, a senior,  a city official or a developer), and the collaborators assumed these positions for a conversation – while a silent audience watched.

IMG_3761

The intricacies of these simultaneous dialogues were challenging  to capture.

IMG_3758IMG_3839

Yet the thing that stands out the most to me now is how amorphous, dexterous, and fluid the atmosphere became  as the different voices of these intelligent and passionate people intermixed, questioned, and persuaded  one another to see the different angles to complex social needs, assets and relationships.

IMG_3906

While the light slanted through the windows and engulfed Dave’s group, the cast shadow of the exhibition wall claimed Sara’s table within its dim, warm hues. For me, the manifestation of time’s passing – as the shrinking light of day was overtaken by growing shadows – invoked a sense of the endless necessity for community endeavor and initiative (and  created a constant need to adjust the exposure time on my camera :•)).

IMG_3864IMG_3881IMG_3909

Participants were also asked to draw out their ideal community, and center collaboration and negotiation in the decision making process by attempting to include all the different community roles that had been assigned.

IMG_3972

Finally, the groups rejoined into one and the barrier of silence was broken for the inactive audience members. The irony of the exclusion of the audience from the discussion up to now, was that it mimicked in many ways how many voices can be left out of dialogues about how their community will change.

IMG_3973IMG_4021

Together, we reflected on our perceptions of the larger framework of this workshop, as well as the necessities, oversights and dead ends within community art endeavors that seek to center equity, belonging, and empowerment. We questioned whether our passions and our labors are actually well placed. Yet we also found points of commonality in seeking authentic relationships, and an understanding that to make art is to love, and being able to express love is essential to life. Art is the bridge, so it matters how we build it.

IMG_4005Follow this link for a document that records the processes and collected comments from the conversation: Placekeeping Notes & Reflections.

 

Report by Rocket Grants Intern Dexter Melton

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s